Forex Community Place

Dapatkan hingga
$50000
karena mengundang teman
untuk memperoleh Bonus StartUp
dari InstaForex
Tidak perlu investasi!
Dapatkan bonus
55%
ke akun anda!
Page 1 of 101
1 2 3 11 51 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 1007

Thread: Regulasi Broker Forex, Pentingkah Bagi Anda? [Part 2]

  1. #1 Collapse Post
    Forum Guru
    Psychedelic
     
    Almas has a reputation beyond repute Almas has a reputation beyond repute Almas has a reputation beyond repute Almas has a reputation beyond repute Almas has a reputation beyond repute Almas has a reputation beyond repute Almas has a reputation beyond repute Almas has a reputation beyond repute Almas has a reputation beyond repute Almas has a reputation beyond repute Almas has a reputation beyond repute Almas's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2014
    Posts
    9,049
    Accrued Payments
    3952 USD (What is this?)
    Saya bertemu tamu
    10 (detail lebih lanjut)
    Thanks
    3,059
    Thanked 9,930 Times in 2,796 Posts

    Regulasi Broker Forex, Pentingkah Bagi Anda? [Part 2]


    Sebelumnya ane mohon maap buat om mimin dan om momod bilamana ada thread yang serupa, ane persilahkan untuk menghapus thread nya. Dan bilamana thread ini salah tempat, mohon untuk bersedia memindahkannya.

    Ane memberanikan diri membuka thread ini, karena ane konsen dalam masalah legalitas broker forex untuk melindungi keamanan para trader. Sekalian dijadikan ajang diskusi mengenai seluk beluk regulasi broker forex.

    Attachment 60452



    --- Regulasi Broker Forex ---


    Salah satu kriteria paling penting buat trader forex dalam memilih broker forex mana yang paling tepat adalah status regulasi broker forex tersebut. Broker forex yang melakukan aktivitas tanpa adanya regulasi bisa menimbulkan resiko terhadap keamanan uang investor. Mereka bisa berbuat apapun diluar hukum (out of law) yang bisa merugikan, khususnya para investor. Tujuan dari badan regulator ini adalah untuk mengawasi dan mengontrol seluruh aktivitas broker forex yang makin berkembang pesat. Selain itu, juga bertujuan untuk melindungi keamanan para investor.

    Broker forex yang reputable setidaknya punya 1 regulasi yang mengaturnya. Makin banyak regulasi, makin bisa dipercaya broker forex tersebut. Selain regulasi, beberapa broker forex juga butuh keanggotaan (membership) dari badan-badan professional dan pemerintah, seperti Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID).

    Jika broker forex tersebut punya regulasi, nama badan regulator seharusnya tercantum di homepage website broker. Namun, terkadang dalam homepage tersebut tidak dicantumkan atau hanya dicantumkan sebagian. Opsi lain adalah mencarinya di page-page yang mengarah ke informasi tentang broker tersebut, seperti di page 'About Us'. Kalau disitu juga tidak dicantumkan, berarti kita harus sedikit waspada. Opsi terakhir adalah menanyakan langsung kepada CS broker tersebut mengenai regulasi.


    Dibawah ini ane sampaikan beberapa badan regulator broker forex yang harus trader forex kenal :

    1. Australia -- Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC)
      "ASIC is Australia's corporate, markets and financial services regulator.
      We contribute to Australia's economic reputation and wellbeing by ensuring that Australia's financial markets are fair and transparent, supported by confident and informed investors and consumers."

    2. Belgia -- The Financial Services and Markets Authority (FSMA)
      "FSMA strives to ensure the honest and equitable treatment of financial consumers and the integrity of the financial markets.
      The various players in the Belgian financial sector are under permanent supervision, for different aspects of their business, in order to secure confidence in the financial markets and to see to it that investors and financial consumers are treated honestly, fairly and professionally."

    3. Belize -- International Financial Services Commission (IFSC)
      "IFSC Act which seeks to promote, protect and enhance Belize as an international financial services center and to regulate the provision of international financial services."

    4. Canada -- Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of Canada (IIROC)
      "IIROC carries out its regulatory responsibilities through setting and enforcing rules regarding the proficiency, business and financial conduct of dealer firms and their registered employees and through setting and enforcing market integrity rules regarding trading activity on Canadian equity marketplaces."

    5. Cyprus -- Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC)
      "CySEC is the independent public supervisory Authority responsible for the supervision of the investment services market and transactions in transferable securities carried out in the Republic of Cyprus.
      The mission is to exercise effective supervision to ensure investor protection and the healthy development of the securities market."

    6. Germany -- Federal Financial Supervisory Authority (BaFin)
      "BaFin brings together under one roof the supervision of banks and financial services providers, insurance undertakings and securities trading. It is an autonomous public-law institution and is subject to the legal and technical oversight of the Federal Ministry of Finance."

    7. Italy - Commissione Nazionale per le Societ? e la Borsa (CONSOB)
      "CONSOB is the public authority responsible for regulating the Italian financial markets.
      Its activity is aimed at the protection of the investing public."

    8. Japan -- Financial Services Agency of Japan (FSA Japan)
      "The Japanese Financial Services Agency is responsible for overseeing banking, securities and exchange, and insurance in order to ensure the stability of the financial system of Japan."

    9. Malta -- Malta Financial Services Authority (FSA in Malta)
      "MFSA is the single regulator for financial services in Malta.
      The financial services sector incorporates all financial activity including that of credit institutions, financial and electronic money institutions, securities and investment services companies, regulated markets, insurance companies, pension schemes and trustees. The MFSA also manages the Registry of Companies and has also been appointed as the Listing Authority."

    10. New Zealand -- Financial Markets Authority (FMA)
      "The FMA's main objective is to promote and facilitate the development of fair, efficient and transparent financial markets."

    11. Russia -- FFMS in Russia (FSFR)
      "The Federal Financial Markets Service was a Russian federal executive body which regulated Russian financial markets including securities issuance and trading and supervision of exchanges, issuers, professional market participants and their Self-Regulatory Organisations."

    12. Russia -- Centre for Regulation of Off-Exchange Financial Instruments and Technologies (CRFIN)
      "CRFIN is a non-profit self-regulated partnership aimed to make the retail off-exchange Forex market a rightful member of the Russian financial industry.
      Our mission is to promote creating effective mechanisms at the off-exchange segment of the Forex market which are necessary for development, transparency, civilized and convenient business environment and protection of interests for market participants."

    13. Switzerland -- Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA)
      "FINMA is an institution under public law with its own legal personality. It is responsible for implementing the Financial Market Supervision Act and financial market legislation. As an independent supervisory authority, FINMA acts to protect the interests of creditors, investors and insured persons and to ensure the proper functioning of the financial markets."

    14. United Kingdom -- UK Financial Services Authority (FSA UK)
      "The FSA has now become two separate regulatory authorities, Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA)."

    15. United Kingdom -- The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA)
      "We regulate the financial services industry in the UK. Our aim is to protect consumers, ensure our industry remains stable and promote healthy competition between financial services providers."

    16. United Kingdom -- The Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA)
      "The PRA is responsible for the supervision of banks, building societies and credit unions, insurers and major investment firms. The PRA's role is defined in terms of two statutory objectives to promote the safety and soundness of these firms and – specifically for insurers – to contribute to the securing of an appropriate degree of protection for policyholders."

    17. United States -- Commodities and Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)
      "The mission of CFTC is to protect market participants and the public from fraud, manipulation, abusive practices and systemic risk related to derivatives – both futures and swaps – and to foster transparent, open, competitive and financially sound markets."

    18. United States -- Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA)
      "FINRA is dedicated to investor protection and market integrity through effective and efficient regulation of the securities industry."

    19. United States -- National Futures Association (NFA)
      "NFA is the self-regulatory organization for the U.S. derivatives industry, including on-exchange traded futures, retail off-exchange foreign currency (forex) and OTC derivatives (swaps)."

    20. International organizations -- EU Commission
      "The European Commission (EC) is the executive body of the European Union responsible for proposing legislation, implementing decisions, upholding the EU treaties and managing the day-to-day business of the EU."



    Selain sebagai ajang diskusi, thread ini bertujuan supaya para trader tahu, regulasi macam apa sih yang dimiliki broker kita ..

    Ga nolak jempol juga kog om, meskipun kepencet ..




    Last edited by behong; 06-01-2017 at 03:45.

  2. 13 Users Say Thank:

    AFLAH89 (09-18-2018), AzmiRosy (09-29-2019), ferryku0905 (08-13-2019), israhmi08 (03-30-2019), Khoirulhuda (05-19-2019), Mantul (07-17-2019), mashtereko22 (07-21-2019), Maskhun (10-25-2017), mentari8 (03-30-2019), MilenialTrader (08-09-2019), mufid1993 (05-05-2019), Natakusumah (01-28-2020), selametd (05-12-2019)

  3. <a href="">Forex Portal MT5</a>
  4. #2 Collapse Post
    Moderator
    Jahat
     
    behong has a reputation beyond repute behong has a reputation beyond repute behong has a reputation beyond repute behong has a reputation beyond repute behong has a reputation beyond repute behong has a reputation beyond repute behong has a reputation beyond repute behong has a reputation beyond repute behong has a reputation beyond repute behong has a reputation beyond repute behong has a reputation beyond repute behong's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    Location
    Di Dalam Keranda
    Posts
    47,185
    Saya bertemu tamu
    2 (detail lebih lanjut)
    Thanks
    13,552
    Thanked 16,328 Times in 8,667 Posts

  5. #3 Collapse Post
    Forum Veteran
    Santai
     
    lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2016
    Posts
    4,864
    Accrued Payments
    4908 USD (What is this?)
    Saya bertemu tamu
    17 (detail lebih lanjut)
    Thanks
    4,150
    Thanked 6,399 Times in 1,958 Posts
    apakah instaforex sudah teregulasi oleh regulator 11. FFMS in Russia (FSFR) dan 12. Centre for Regulation of Off-Exchange Financial Instruments and Technologies (CRFIN) atau belum ?
    kalau memnag sudah berarti pernyataan tentang instaforex merupakan broker tanpa regulasi itu salah.
    dengan begitu menjadi semakin terasa aman trading bersama instaforex.

  6. #4 Collapse Post
    Guru Honorer dari MT5
    Benguk
     
    acefx has a reputation beyond repute acefx has a reputation beyond repute acefx has a reputation beyond repute acefx has a reputation beyond repute acefx has a reputation beyond repute acefx has a reputation beyond repute acefx has a reputation beyond repute acefx has a reputation beyond repute acefx has a reputation beyond repute acefx has a reputation beyond repute acefx has a reputation beyond repute acefx's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2010
    Posts
    27,706
    Accrued Payments
    7228 USD (What is this?)
    Saya bertemu tamu
    5 (detail lebih lanjut)
    Thanks
    3,153
    Thanked 3,196 Times in 2,472 Posts
    Black Frame Talent: Kontes Demotivator pada Forum MT5.com
    Quote Originally Posted by lebe wadas     
    apakah instaforex sudah teregulasi oleh regulator 11. FFMS in Russia (FSFR) dan 12. Centre for Regulation of Off-Exchange Financial Instruments and Technologies (CRFIN) atau belum ?
    kalau memnag sudah berarti pernyataan tentang instaforex merupakan broker tanpa regulasi itu salah.
    dengan begitu menjadi semakin terasa aman trading bersama instaforex.
    Perlu diketahui tidak ada istilah regulasi di negara rusia, yang ada istilah asosiasi.
    Sangat betul gan, broker instaforex jadinya tidak pernah teregulasi. Namun terasosiasi.

    Regulasi artinya dibawah nanguan Badan Negara contoh CFTC atau NFA.
    Di rusia gak ada badannya, sehingga broker broker membuat asosiasi mandiri.

    Badan yang anda sebutkan CRFIN itu asosiasi bukan regulasi.

  7. #5 Collapse Post
    Master Honorer
    Yeehaw
     
    ariezz has a reputation beyond repute ariezz has a reputation beyond repute ariezz has a reputation beyond repute ariezz has a reputation beyond repute ariezz has a reputation beyond repute ariezz has a reputation beyond repute ariezz has a reputation beyond repute ariezz has a reputation beyond repute ariezz has a reputation beyond repute ariezz has a reputation beyond repute ariezz has a reputation beyond repute ariezz's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2013
    Location
    klaten
    Posts
    14,959
    Accrued Payments
    9601 USD (What is this?)
    Saya bertemu tamu
    6 (detail lebih lanjut)
    Thanks
    780
    Thanked 5,507 Times in 3,656 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by lebe wadas     
    apakah instaforex sudah teregulasi oleh regulator 11. FFMS in Russia (FSFR) dan 12. Centre for Regulation of Off-Exchange Financial Instruments and Technologies (CRFIN) atau belum ?
    kalau memnag sudah berarti pernyataan tentang instaforex merupakan broker tanpa regulasi itu salah.
    dengan begitu menjadi semakin terasa aman trading bersama instaforex.
    sejak dulu setau saya insta memang belum atau tidak teregulasi gan, regulasi disini adalah badan yang mengawasi perdagangan berjangkan seperti forex dan sebagainya agar broker atau pialang tidak bisa berbuat curang.

    Perlu diketahui tidak ada istilah regulasi di negara rusia, yang ada istilah asosiasi.
    Sangat betul gan, broker instaforex jadinya tidak pernah teregulasi. Namun terasosiasi.

    Regulasi artinya dibawah nanguan Badan Negara contoh CFTC atau NFA.
    Di rusia gak ada badannya, sehingga broker broker membuat asosiasi mandiri.

    Badan yang anda sebutkan CRFIN itu asosiasi bukan regulasi.
    ternyata memang benar ya gan acefx kalau regulator yang resmi itu memang hanya ada di negara tertentu seperti amrik, inggris dan australia. kalau begitu berarti misalnya ada broker di negara di luar regulator tetap bisa menggunakan regulator negara lain?

  8. #6 Collapse Post
    Veteran Honorer MT5
    Bahagia
     
    ngatno has a reputation beyond repute ngatno has a reputation beyond repute ngatno has a reputation beyond repute ngatno has a reputation beyond repute ngatno has a reputation beyond repute ngatno has a reputation beyond repute ngatno has a reputation beyond repute ngatno has a reputation beyond repute ngatno has a reputation beyond repute ngatno has a reputation beyond repute ngatno has a reputation beyond repute ngatno's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Semarang
    Posts
    10,756
    Accrued Payments
    6015 USD (What is this?)
    Saya bertemu tamu
    1 (detail lebih lanjut)
    Thanks
    16,456
    Thanked 19,789 Times in 7,558 Posts
    regulasi menjadi pertimbangan nomor 1 bagi saya untuk memilih broker. secara gampang memang semakin banyak regulasi semakin aman bagi kita meskipun hal itu belum tentu. hanya regulasi di negara maju saja sebenarnya yang bisa dijadikan pegangan supaya kita angggap aman broker bersangkutan. meskipun sebenarnya broker yang berada di negara kecil juga belum tentu dikategorikan scam. yang penting kita selalu waspada dan melihat pengalaman trader lain supaya modal tetap aman.

  9. #7 Collapse Post
    Poster Setia
    Lembut
     
    ARORIFLAME has a reputation beyond repute ARORIFLAME has a reputation beyond repute ARORIFLAME has a reputation beyond repute ARORIFLAME has a reputation beyond repute ARORIFLAME has a reputation beyond repute ARORIFLAME has a reputation beyond repute ARORIFLAME has a reputation beyond repute ARORIFLAME has a reputation beyond repute ARORIFLAME has a reputation beyond repute ARORIFLAME has a reputation beyond repute ARORIFLAME has a reputation beyond repute ARORIFLAME's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2017
    Location
    DAPUR FOREX
    Posts
    2,867
    Accrued Payments
    1374 USD (What is this?)
    Saya bertemu tamu
    1 (detail lebih lanjut)
    Thanks
    1,649
    Thanked 4,326 Times in 2,087 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by ngatno     
    regulasi menjadi pertimbangan nomor 1 bagi saya untuk memilih broker. secara gampang memang semakin banyak regulasi semakin aman bagi kita meskipun hal itu belum tentu. hanya regulasi di negara maju saja sebenarnya yang bisa dijadikan pegangan supaya kita angggap aman broker bersangkutan. meskipun sebenarnya broker yang berada di negara kecil juga belum tentu dikategorikan scam. yang penting kita selalu waspada dan melihat pengalaman trader lain supaya modal tetap aman.
    saya termasuk tipe trader yang masih recehan ommm.....dan belum masuk kategori trader kelas paus dengan dana di atas ratusan juta sehingga bagi saya broker teregulasi luar negeri tetap sama saja.....kecuali sekalian broker yang teregulasi di bappeti indonesia sehingga tidak ada kendala jika suatu saat pajak akan masuk kedalam dunia forex atau perdagaan online.....sehinga kata orang tua kepada anak muda.....apabila kita siap trading forex maka juga harus siap kehilangan uang tidak hanya dari pasar tetapi juga dari broker jika terjadi suatu bencana.

  10. #8 Collapse Post
    Forum Veteran
    Santai
     
    lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas has a reputation beyond repute lebe wadas's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2016
    Posts
    4,864
    Accrued Payments
    4908 USD (What is this?)
    Saya bertemu tamu
    17 (detail lebih lanjut)
    Thanks
    4,150
    Thanked 6,399 Times in 1,958 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by acefx     
    Perlu diketahui tidak ada istilah regulasi di negara rusia, yang ada istilah asosiasi.
    Sangat betul gan, broker instaforex jadinya tidak pernah teregulasi. Namun terasosiasi.

    Regulasi artinya dibawah nanguan Badan Negara contoh CFTC atau NFA.
    Di rusia gak ada badannya, sehingga broker broker membuat asosiasi mandiri.

    Badan yang anda sebutkan CRFIN itu asosiasi bukan regulasi.
    terimakasih om acefx atas penjelasannya.
    soalnya dithread sebelah masih sering saya temukan member yang mengatakan bahwa instaforex sudah teregulasi di negara asalnya yaitu rusia. sedangkan dari hasil pencarian saya di google ternyata memang dirusia tidak ada badan pemerintah yang memberikan lisensi untuk bisnis di bidang forex.
    sekarang jadi tau mana yang benar.

  11. #9 Collapse Post
    Guru Honorer dari MT5
    Polos
     
    NdeUnyil has a reputation beyond repute NdeUnyil has a reputation beyond repute NdeUnyil has a reputation beyond repute NdeUnyil has a reputation beyond repute NdeUnyil has a reputation beyond repute NdeUnyil has a reputation beyond repute NdeUnyil has a reputation beyond repute NdeUnyil has a reputation beyond repute NdeUnyil has a reputation beyond repute NdeUnyil has a reputation beyond repute NdeUnyil has a reputation beyond repute NdeUnyil's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2016
    Location
    East Java
    Posts
    18,024
    Accrued Payments
    14327 USD (What is this?)
    Saya bertemu tamu
    7 (detail lebih lanjut)
    Thanks
    62,617
    Thanked 65,313 Times in 15,798 Posts
    Kalau instaforex tidak masuk broker regulasi di indonesia, apakah kegiatan trading masyarakat indonesia tidak di akui bahkan nanti dikatakan melanggar aturan atau hukum yang berlaku sehingga ada sanksi yang bisa dikenakan pada trader oleh pemerintah.

  12. #10 Collapse Post
    Poster Lama
    Halus
     
    uings79 will become famous soon enough uings79 will become famous soon enough uings79's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Posts
    3,663
    Accrued Payments
    592 USD (What is this?)
    Thanks
    32
    Thanked 155 Times in 137 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by NdeUnyil     
    Kalau instaforex tidak masuk broker regulasi di indonesia, apakah kegiatan trading masyarakat indonesia tidak di akui bahkan nanti dikatakan melanggar aturan atau hukum yang berlaku sehingga ada sanksi yang bisa dikenakan pada trader oleh pemerintah.
    Setau ane untuk instaforex masih belum terdaftar dalam broker regulasi diindonesia, tapi walaupun seperti itu, dimungkinkan ada persyaratan yang dikeluarkan dari regulator yang tidak sesuai dengan rule yang dibuat dari instaforex itu sendiri sehingga mereka belum tertarik mengikuti regulasi di Indonesia

Page 1 of 101
1 2 3 11 51 ... LastLast
Please read recommendations on how to write popular and useful posts in the Contest of the Best Answers Please read recommendations on how to write popular and useful posts in the Best Content Contest

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts